Friday, January 25, 2013

GLOVER FAMILY-from England/Delaware to Glover's Gap

Glover Gap district

The following is quoted directly from a 36 page typescript history prepared by Avril A. Ash and released in 1967.
"John Glover, the progenitor of our branch of the Glover family, emigrated from England to America in 1755 and settled in Wilmington, Delaware. This information is from two sources - (a) 'History of West Virginia,' by Sylvester Myers, a great-great grandson of John Glover, the immigrant, and (b) 'A Genealogy of the Mittong Family and Connections,' by Benjamin Franklin Wilson, who was connected to the Glover family by the marriage of his grandfather, Jacob Mittong (chapter five). Both accounts say he was a young man when he arrived in America, and the year of his birth is placed at about 1735 to 1740. Shortly after his arrival here, he married a girl from New England, name not known, and there were at least two children, Amos and Nehemiah, Amos having been born in 1760 and Nehemiah about 1772. In 1781, which year is questioned on the grounds of Nehemiah being but nine years of age at that time, the two sons came west and settled insouthwestern Pennsylvania, Amos settling in what is now Washington County and Nehemiah in Green County.

(Below:  pages from Wilson's book)

Thursday, January 24, 2013

TOWNSENDS OF OYSTER BAY (from England to Michigan)


[for full text of Townsend family records dating back to 11th Century, click here . ]

(Note how a combination of online genealogical sources can carry a family line back in time -in this case to the 12th Century.)

Sir Ludoric (Lodovicus) of Townshend (fl 1100) married Elizabeth de Hauteville of Roynhom, Norfolk, daughter and heir of Thomas de Hauteville, who received his lands from William the Conqueror.
Walter Atte Townshende, sometimes referred to as Walter Ad Finem Ville, Ad Exitum Ville, or Atte Towneshende, all traditionally meaning "at town's end," but in Norman dialect could be "town holder." The silent "h" and the final "e" were dropped about 1500 as superfluous, returning to the noble branch of the family soon after 1580. see The Townshend Family of Lynn in Old and New England by Charles Henry Townshend, 1882
Thomas Atte Tunneshende (1247-1272)
John Tunneshende (1265-1304) married Alice
William Tunneshende (c1285)
Peter Atte Townshende (c1305-after1371)
Roger de Townshende (1325-1400) married about 1349 Catherine Atherton of Sussex, daughter of John de Atherton of Sussex (c1295)
Sir Thomas de Townshende, Lord of Raynham (c1355-1 Apr 1421) married about 1379 Agnes Payne, daughter of William Payne. Lived at Raynham, Norfolk
Sir Roger Townshend (c1360-Feb 1466) married Eleanor Giggs of Rollesby, Norfolk, daughter of Thomas Giggs. Lived at Raynham, Norfolk.
Sir John Townshend (c1400-16 Feb 1465/6) married Agnes; or Joan, daughter of Sir Robert Lunsford

Sir Roger Townshend (c1430-9 Nov 1493) married Eleanor Lundsford (c1430-8 Oct 1500) daughter of William Lunsford and Thomasine Barrington of Sussex. Sir Roger was a lawyer, justice, and Member of Parliament, lived at Raynham, Norfolk. 

Sir Roger Townsend (1477-25 Nov 1552) married Anne de Brewse(1474-25 Jul 1551) daughter of Sir William de Brewse of Stinton Hall and Elizabeth Hopton. Sir Roger was a lawyer, justice, sheriff, Member of Parliament, and Commissioner for several causes. He greatly expanded his estates, centered at Raynham.
Raynham Hall is said to be one of the most splendid of the great houses of Norfolk. It was begun in 1619 by [a later] Sir Roger Townshend and was unique at that time in England. Perhaps influenced by a 3-year 'grand tour' of Europe, Townshend built it in a new style following the Italian form and plan.
[FYI for any of you 'ghost hunters' -Raynham is supposedly haunted!]
Sir Robert Townsend (1512-8 Feb 1555/6) m.1 Oct 1534 Alice Poppy (1510) daughter of Sir Robert Poppy of Twyford, Norfolk. Justice of the Peace, Sergeant-at-Law, Lord Chief Justice of Chester. Lived in Ludlow, Shropshire. Knighted in 1545  
Notes for Robert Townshend:
Sir Robert Townshend, like his father and grandfather before him, was trained in the law. He was admitted to The Honourable Society of Lincoln's Inn, one of four barrister Inns of Court in London.  During the early part of the reign of Henry VIII, Sir Robert became eminent in the study of law, being retained by Queen Jane Seymour. He was sufficiently distinguished to be appointed Serjeant-at -law in 1540 and King's Serjeant in 1541. In May 1541 he was elevated to the Bench as Lord Chief Justice of Chester.
He was later Knighted by Henry VIII at Hampton Court on Trinity Sunday in 1545 and was a member of the Council in the Principality and Marches of Wales.
Sir Robert Townsend married Alice Poppy, the daughter of Robert Poppy of Twyford in Norfolk on
 1 October 1516. By right of his wife's family, Sir Robert possessed the advowson of Twyford, and in that capacity appointed Robert Jary vicar of Twyford in 1541, and Robert Watson to the same position in 1554.
Sir Robert died on 8 February 1556/7, possessed of the manors and rectories of Twyford and Guyst, the manors of Swanton, Foxley and Southwell in Norfolk and the priory house of St. Augustine in Ludlow, Shropshire.
He was buried in the high chancel of Ludlow Parish Church in an altar tomb. On the top of the tomb, which still exists in excellent condition, are the full length recumbent figures of the old knight in full armour, and his lady dressed in the costume of the day, while figures of the children surround the tomb.  
Tomb of Sir Robert Townshend, Ludlow Parish Church

(the order of children not specified in source)
. 1. Thomas Townsend (d.1591) m.1558 Elizabeth Periente; see below
. 2. Robert Townsend (buried 28 Aug 1614) m.30 Apr 1571 Anne Machell (Marshall); of Ludlow, Shropshire; sons: Sir John (1572-1630), Robert, Nicholas, Sydney, Thomas, Henry, Edward.
. 3. Isaac Townsend (1535-3 Jun 1621)
. 4. Sir Henry Townsend (1537-9 Dec 1621) m(1) Susan Hayward; daughter of Sir Rowland; m(2)   Dorothy Heveningham; of Cande, Shropshire. sons: Hayward (1577-1604), John (1592), Henry
. 5. Thomasin Townsend (1538) m(1) William Curson; m(2) William Rugge Repps
. 6. Anne (Amice) Townsend married Raffe (Ralph) Dutton
. 7. daughter Townsend married Richard Smythe
. 8. Bridget Townsend married Henry Acton
. 9. Grace Townsend married Ambrose Gilbert
10. Alice Townsend (d.1617) m(1) Humphrey Archer; m(2) Edward

Thomas Townsend (1533 - 1591)
Thomas Townsend (d.15 Jun 1591) m.25 Jun 1558 Elizabeth Periente (1536-20 Jun 1580), daughter of George Periente. Thomas married(2) 1581/2 Anne d'Oyly, daughter of Henry d'Oyly (d.1591) several of their children died young, only Alice and Mary surviving. 
Mergate Hall
Notes for Thomas Townshend:
Sir Robert Townshend's eldest son Thomas inherited most of his father's properties and resided at Mergate Hall at Bracon Ash in Norfolk. He was a man of great wealth and possessions and kept considerable state at Mergate Hall;
Queen Elizabeth I dined with Thomas and his wife there in July 1578.
Thomas' wife was Elizabeth, the widow of Sir Humphrey Style, and although he conformed to the reformed religion she refused to do so and remained a Catholic. This refusal to conform prompted the Bishop of Norwich to write to Thomas in 1571, ending his letter with the following admonishment:
"...My duty and place of calling, together with my conscience Godward, cannot suffer me to know such disorder, and to suffer the same any longer, and, therefore, I desire you both from henceforth to frequent the Church and receive the sacrament, as becometh Christians, as I may be certified forthwith, both of the one and of the other, which I look for; otherwise, this is most assured, I will not fail to complain of you both to Her Majesty's Council, wherewith neither of you shall have just cause to be offended, since you are so friendly admonished of your faults and have so long a time to amend. And thus I bid you heartily farewell.
John, Bishop of Norwich."
Thomas Townsend had several children and died in June 1591. One of his daughters married Ambrose Clive, and was the
ancestor in the sixth generation of Robert, Lord Clive of India, who established the British Empire in India.

His only surviving son, Henry, lived at Gedding in Suffolk and died in 1625. Henry Townsend's son, Thomas, settled at Lynn, in the Massachusetts Bay Colony in North America in 1636 and died there in 1677. His descendants are prolific and are now scattered all over the United States.
From "Ancestors of Zoe Townsend & Walker Dix"

Henry Townsend (1568 - 1625)
Son of Thomas
Henry Townsend (31 May 1568-22 Aug 1625) m.5 Nov 1590 Margaret Forthe (1570-23 Jun 1596) daughter of Robert Forthe (d.23 Jul 1596) and Martha Box; married at St John Zacharias in London. lived in Bracon-Ash, Norfolk, until 1599, when he sold it and moved to Gedding, Suffolk. He m(2) Anne Calthorpe, daughter of Bertram Calthorpe.
Thomas Townsend (1594 - 1677)
Son of Henry
Thomas Townsend (8 Jan 1594/5-22 Dec 1677) m.1613 Mary Newgate (1598-28 Feb 1691/2) daughter of Phillip Newgate and Joan Hoo; and a cousin of Governor Winthrop. After his father sold Bracon-Ash in 1599, Thomas lived with his father in Gedding, Suffolk, until reaching his majority in 1615, when he went to London to live with his uncle Thomas Forthe, son of Robert Forthe (d.1595). Thomas emigrated from London to Lynn, Massachusetts, in 1637, aboard the Handmaid along with his sons Henry, John, and Richard.

Thomas was granted 60 acres of land with Lord Brook and others by the town of Lynn, in 1638, and he owned other lands near the iron works and at Rumney Marsh, Chelsea. His town-house and lot of 7 acres was on the south side the mill street near the common, and next the Mansfield property, and it was sold by his grandson Thomas, son of Andrew, to Daniel Mansfield, of Lynn, July 25, 1702.  He was made a freeman March 14, 1639, calling himself husbandman in his well-drawn deeds of gift to his children. He died in Lynn, Dec. 22, 1677, aged 83, and his wife Mary died of camp-fever, probably at the house of her son Andrew, Feb. 28, 1692.
They reportedly had the following children [note that Henry and his brothers, John and Richard, were from Thomas's first marriage. -The children below were their half-siblings]:
2. i. Thomas, born about 1637.
3. ii. Samuel, b. in Lynn about 1638.
4. iii. John, b. in Lynn about 1640.
5. iv. Andrew, b. in Lynn about 1642.
v. Elizabeth, b. in Lynn about 1644; m. Samuel Mansfield, of Lynn, Dec. 22, 1669.
NOTE:  The following statement is attached to show that some researchers disagree: "Three brothers traditionally from Norwich, Norfolk, [HENRY, JOHN, & RICHARD] came to New Amsterdam before 1643. They were not believed to be sons of Thomas Townsend of Lynn, but related - probably descendants of Sir Robert Townsend and Alice Poppy above. Henry reportedly came first, then returned to England and persuaded his brothers to join him" [Until proof to the contrary is found, I will maintain that there is direct lineage through Thomas as their father] .
Henry Townsend (1626 - 1695)
Son of Thomas  [Henry and his brother John are featured in the story posted on 4/913: "By Twig & Turf ~family roots in Oyster Bay"]
Henry Townsend (1649 - 1703)
Son of Henry
Henry Townsend (1649-1703) was the son of Henry Townsend who emigrated to the colonies from England. Eventually Henry Townsend settled in Oyster Bay, where his son Henry Townsend was raised.  Townsend Society of America DNA testing project has established that the Oyster Bay family is not related to Thomas Townsend of Lynn, MA. The county of origin in England for Henry, John and Richard Townsend is not known. Henry Townsend married Deborah Underhill in 1657. Deborah Underhill (1659-1698) was daughter of Captain John Underhill* (1597-1672), another important figure in Colonial America who trained the militia of the Massachusetts Bay Colony and served as magistrate of Flushing for a brief period of time, before settling on 150 acres of land outside of Oyster Bay. 
*Captain Underhill was converted to Quakerism by his second wife, Elizabeth Feake, thus making the union of Henry Townsend and Deborah Underhill the combining of two of the most influential Quaker families in Oyster Bay.
Deborah and Henry had at least four children together: Robert (b. 1687), Elizabeth (1692-1756), Henry (d. 1709) and Uriah Townsend (1698-1767).

Uriah Townsend (1698 - 1767)
Son of Henry
Robert Townsend (1728 - 1803)
Son of Uriah

Uriah Townsend (1753 - 1804)
Son of Robert

Ezra Edwin Townsend (1788 - 185-)
Son of Uriah

Ezra Edwin Townsend was born on August 30, 1788 in the village of Catskill, in Greene County,  New York. He died on March 13, 1851 in Washtenaw County, Michigan.
Wife, Janet/Jennet Trumbull  (1791-1835) and Ezra were parents of:
Rebecca Townsend (1808 - 1878)  who married George Walter Watson, parents of:
Rebecca Townsend Watson
Marietta Watson (1830 - 1890)
who married John M. Amrhine, parents of:

Emma Jane Amrhine, Emerine (1860 - 1933)
wife of William R. Smith, parents of my grandfather:

Leon Vern Smith (1897 - 1947)

Tuesday, January 22, 2013


UNDERHILL/SMITH  9thGGF Captain John Underhill, 1630 immigrant
The journey back to Queen Elizabeth's "Keeper of the Wardrobe" -direct ancestry of the Underhill family from Hunningham, Warwickshire, England to Oyster Bay, Long Island, New York:
 as far back as:

Sir Hugh Underhill (1518 - 1593)
 On 6 Feb 1563 he was appointed by Queen Elizabeth Keeper of the Wardrobe at the King's Manor at Greenwich. In 1563 he was elevated to be responsible for the Wardrobe of Beds. (This position was one of the highest maintaining the countless hangings of tapestry and the Cloths of State, the great carpets and all upholstering of chairs, stools, curtains, bedsteads, and more. In 1590 he was appointed by the Queen as Keeper of the Garden in the manor of East Greenwich. He is mentioned in several wills of the Royal Household, an indication that he was held in high regard.

Sir Thomas Underhill (1545 - 1591)
Thomas was Keeper of the Wardrobe at Kenilworth Castle, to Robert Dudley, 1st Earl of Leicester.  Kenilworth was given to Dudley by Queen Elizabeth, who would have visited him there during Thomas' appointment. In 1585 the Queen appointed the Earl of Leicester commander of her forces in the Netherlands, fighting with the Dutch against the Spanish. Thomas accompanied the Earl on this assignment. The fact that Thomas Underhill, son of a well-regarded member of her own household (Sir Hugh) was assigned to Kenilworth, shows the affection Queen Elizabeth I had both for Dudley and Underhill.

John Edward Underhill (1574 - 1608)
Son of Sir Thomas
John Underhill was a friend and companion to the Earls of Leicester and Essex, and while a youth held a commission in the Earl of Leicester's own Troop of Guards, that was sent to the assistance of the Dutch by Queen Elizabeth I. When the Netherlands offered their sovereignty to the Earl of Leicester, John Edward Underhill was the bearer of confidential dispatches to Lord Burleigh, the Queen's Minister. After the fall and execution of Leicester, he attached himself to the Earl of Essex. He accompanied Essex who captured Cadiz, Spain for the King of France, and was part of Devereux's expedition to the Azores, where Underhill was listed as dead in the muster rolls of Capt. Roger Orme's Company, 1608. 

Following his father's death, John Jr. and his siblings lived with his mother, HONOR/LEONORA PAWLEY (b. 1575, Cornwall) in the Netherlands with a group of Puritan exiles. While there he received military training as a cadet in the service of Philip Willam, the Prince of Orange, a great military strategist. She immigrated to the colonies in 1630, probably in the company of her son, John and his first wife and children.

Capt. John Underhill, Immigrant 1630
Son of John Edward
JOHN born near Kenilworth England about 1597.  He first married (1) Heylken (Helena) de Hooch 12 Dec 1628 at the Kloosterkerk at the Hague, Holland who died at Southold LI NY before 19 Aug 1658. He then married (2) ELIZABETH FEAKE  in 1658 Southold LI NY. Elizabeth was born about 1633 Watertown MA to Robert Feake and Elizabeth (Fones) Winthrop aka "The Winthrop Woman," and died at Killingworth Oyster Bay LI before 4 Nov 1675. 

While in the Netherlands, John was a cadet in the guard of the Prince of Orange in 1628.  It was there that young Captain John Underhill became a fellow soldier of Captain Miles Standish. In 1620, Standish was employed to train the Plymouth Militia. Ten years later John Underhill, now Captain, sailed from Yarmouth with John Winthrop and his nine hundred immigrants to the Bay Colony, under an agreement to train the Militia of the new settlement of Boston.  A year later, Underhill was sworn freeman and was one of the first deputies to the General Court. One of the earliest acts of the new government was to order that the first Thursday of every month be general training day of Captain Underhill's Company, at Boston.
Captains Underhill and Daniel Patrick became the first paid military officers in Massachusetts Bay.

Capt. John Underhill is given credit for the colonists' victory in the Pequot War in 1637 but soon after signed a petition in behalf of Anne Hutchinson and Rev. John Wheelwright and his citizenship rights in the colony were removed. He was banished and went to now called New Hampshire where he served as Governor of Exeter and Dover for a year. In 1641 his banishment was lifted and he returned to Massachusetts Bay Colony for a short time.               

In 1630, Underhill published a book titled: Newes from America; Or, A New and Experimentall Discoverie of New England; Containing, A Trve Relation of Their War-like Proceedings These Two Yeares Last Past, with a Figure of the Indian Fort, or Palizado  

The immigrant, John Underhill, eventually settled on a tract of land he purchased from the Indians, in the town of Oyster Bay, which he named after his birthplace, Kenilworth -spelled Killingworth. He became a member of the Society of Friends in his old age, and here he died in 1672. President Theodore Roosevelt provided a speech at the dedication of a monument to Captain Underhill at the Underhill Burying Ground, Oyster Bay, 1908. 
Descendancy through Capt. John and Elizabeth Feake (dau. of "The Winthrop Woman")
Deborah Underhill (1659 - 1698) married Henry Townsend of Oyster Bay (1649-1703)
Daughter of Capt. John

Uriah Townsend (1698 - 1767)
Son of Deborah

Robert Townsend (1728 - 1803)
Son of Uriah

Uriah Townsend (1753 - 1804)
Son of Robert

Ezra Edwin Townsend (1788 - 1851)
Son of Uriah

Rebecca Townsend (1808 - 1878) married George Walter Watson
Daughter of Ezra Edwin

Marietta Watson (1830 - 1890)
Daughter of Rebecca

Emma Jane Amrhine, Emerine (1860 - 1933)
Daughter of Marietta

Leon Vern Smith 
Son of Emma Jane

Monday, January 21, 2013

QUAKERS: The Light Within

(photo: George Fox, first Quaker leader)

QUAKER ancestors from my dad's GLOVER-MYERS branch include the families of: Bowne, Beakes, Stacy, Potts. My mother's  DORT-THOMAS branch include the Quaker families of: Dyer, Hutchinson.   

Let us not forget that many of our ancestors were very early immigrants to the colonies (pre-Mayflower to early 1700).  As such, they often were affiliated with religious practices frowned upon in post-Elizabethan England.  One group, the Society of Friends, has its roots stretching across the Atlantic from England to the American colonies where the “Quakers,” as they were known, sought refuge from religious repression, fines, and imprisonment.

 At that time, the Church of England was the “official” church of the land and, as such, instituted state-mandated religious worship that was highly ritualistic and ceremonial, based on the newly published King James Bible.  The Puritans, dedicated to ‘purifying’ the Church of England, had already been emigrating to Holland and then America to avoid punishment for their form of worship while seeking the freedom of religion they sought. 

 The Quakers (originally a derogatory term they happily adopted) were also targeted as dissenters to the ‘approved’ religion of England.

Thursday, January 17, 2013


Little Jack Horner sat in the corner
Eating his Christmas pie,
He put in his thumb and pulled out a plum
And said "What a good boy am I!"

According to a number of sources, the rhyme about Little Jack Horner was circulated about 1543 concerning a Thomas Strangeways* Horner. (*wife-Susannah Strangeways) He had acquired the land of the Bishop of Glastonbury, Somersetshire, England, when Henry VIII dissolved the Catholic Church in England and abolished the monasteries from 1536-1539. The deeds for the seized lands were  purportedly secreted in a pie for safe delivery to the King. The metaphoric "plum" was Mells Manor, which Horner plucked for himself from the twelve deeds he was to hand to the King "in the pie". The name "Jack" typically denoted a knave that is a "King's Man" particularly under Henry VIII.

(My Horner family research goes back to 1573 with the names Thomas and John... and may have direct family connections. I will publish lineage once it is further studied. Either way, I thought you'd enjoy the origins of this nursery rhyme!)

Wednesday, January 16, 2013



Lt. Robert Feake 1630 (1602 - 1662) married
Elizabeth Fones Winthrop  (1609-1673); widow of Gov. Winthrop's son, Henry
AKA: "The Winthrop Woman"
Elizabeth Feake (1633 - 1675), Daughter of Lt. Robert
Deborah Underhill (1659 - 1698) Daughter of Elizabeth
Uriah Townsend (1698 - 1767) Son of Deborah
Robert Townsend (1728 - 1803) Son of Uriah
Uriah Townsend (1753 - 1804) Son of Robert
Ezra Edwin Townsend (1788 - 1851) Son of Uriah
Rebecca Townsend (1808 - 1878) Daughter of Ezra Edwin
Marietta Watson (1830 - 1890) Daughter of Rebecca
Emma Jane Amrhine, Emerine (1860 - 1933) Daughter of Marietta
Leon Vern Smith (1897 - 1947) Son of Emma Jane

To tell the story of "The Winthrop Woman" we need to know a little about her husband first:
Robert Feake came to Massachusetts Bay in the fleet with Governor Winthrop, in the year 1630. He married Elizabeth, the young widow of Henry Winthrop (son of the Governor and her first cousin).
He established his homestall[stead] in Watertown, and was grantee and owner of a number of plots in that area.  By May, 1631 he was admitted a freeman of the colony and, as such, could serve as a selectman chosen to order "all civil affaires of ye town."  From 1634-1636 he was representative in the General Court from Watertown after having been appointed Lieutenant to Captain Daniel Patrick, then chief military officer at Watertown and the neighboring settlements.
 He was also appointed by the Court of Boston to be part of a team led by Captain's Underhill (later son-in-law) and Patrick to establish the site for a fort on Castle Island in the Bay.   According to my source, he continued to 'follow the fortunes' of Captain Patrick and in 1639 accompanied him on his removal to Connecticut. In the month of July 1640, together they purchased the Indian-held lands which later became the town of Greenwich Conn. 
 Included in this tract was a parcel of land, named Elizabeth Neck in honor of the wife of Robert Feake, Elizabeth Fones Winslow. (It is said that -although this settlement was made under the sanction and in the interest of the New Haven colony- Director Willem Kieft of New Amsterdam (later New York) soon warned them off as intruders on Dutch Territory. Patrick and Feake persisted and continued for two or more years in the occupation of these lands, harassed and threatened by neighboring Indians until they finally decided to put themselves under the protection of the Dutch.)
From this point on our story takes on a more tragic note for Robert Feake, within a decade -losing his marriage to an unfaithful wife who created a major scandal in a conservative community; -losing his children and his property and, it is said, also losing his mind :
COMMENTS: In his lengthy article on the Feake family (see HENRY FEAKE for full citation), George E. McCracken went into great detail on Robert Feake, and particularly on the matter of his "divorce," arguing that the couple had in fact received only a legal separation, and that Elizabeth (Fones) (Winthrop) Feake was not free to remarry.  In 1966 Donald Lines Jacobus reviewed the same problem, and came to the conclusion that Robert Feake and his wife did obtain a divorce from the Dutch government, that she had married William Hallett by August 1649, and that the marriage was performed by John Winthrop Jr., her cousin and former brother-in-law.

Feake was described as "... a man whose God-fearing heart was so absorbed with spiritual and heavenly things that he little thought of the things of this life, and took neither heed nor care of what was tendered to his external property".

To others he was a "distracted" person who could not manage his estate, and whose lofty connections alone preserved him.  His abrupt return to England in 1647 is not entirely understood. McCracken suggests that the Robert Feake pardoned by the House of Commons 4 March 1649/50 for some unstated crime might be Robert of Watertown. In any event, he left considerable scandal behind him in New England. 

(BLOGGER'S NOTE:  It might also be true that the 'considerable scandal' was not only left behind him, but was acted out during his absence by the friend he left in charge of his property and his unfaithful wife.)

In a letter dated Stamford 14 April 1648, Thomas Lyon related to his "loving grandfather" John Winthrop the history of Mr. Feake and Elizabeth (Fones) Winthrop:
...when I married first I lived in the house with her because my father being distracted I might be a help to her. Whereupon seeing several carriages between the fellow she now hath to be her husband and she the people also took notice of it which was to her disgrace which grieved me very much ... and seeing what condition she were in  I spake to her about it privately and after I discovered my dislike I see her carriage alter toward me ... Father concerning the condition she is in and the children and estate my father Feike going away suddenly, having taken no course about the children and estate only desired a friend of his and I in case we see them about making away the estate and to remove we should stay it ... She also hath confessed since she came there openly she is married to him  is with child by him [blogger's note: but only officially married one year after birth of the child] and she hath been at New Haven but could have no comfort nor hopes for present to live in the jurisdiction and what will become of her I know not [WP 5:213-14].

In a letter dated New Haven 21 July 1648, Theophilus Eaton told John Winthrop Jr.:
...I understand William Hallet etc. are come to your plantation at Nameag, their grievious miscarriage hath certainly given great offense to many. I wish their repentance were as clear and satisfying. It is possible that William Hallet and she that was Mr. Feake's his wife are married, though not only the lawfulness and validity of such a marriage, but the reality and truth is by some questioned, because themselves and Toby Feakes sometimes deny it; but leaving that, I shall acquaint you ... with some passages about that estate. Mr. Feakes from Boston October 6, 1647 wrote to Stamford that he reserved the whole propriety of his estate, till he saw how God would deal with him in England, and desired he and the children might not be wronged etc., after which that estate being from the Dutch in danger of confiscation, they brought it to Stamford, and at their request, it was there seized, as wholly belonging to Mr. Feakes, though after they challenged part thereof as the proper estate of William Hallet, and she besides desired a share in what was due to Mr. Feakes. I was not willing they should be wronged in the least, ... and accordingly at their request, I wrote to Stamford. William Hallet after this brought a letter from your honored father, and told me, he met with some opposition at Stamford, whereupon I advised him to attend the Court of magistrates ... but I perceived in him an unwillingness thereunto.... It was ordered that ... if she settled at Watertown, Pequod, or within any of the English colonies, two of the children, with half Mr. Feakes his proper estate should be put into the power and trust of such English government ... with such respect to Mr. Feakes, as may be meet, and that the other half of the estate should be improved at Stamford for the use of Mr. Feakes and maintenance of the other two children. I hoped that this might have satisfied, but the next news was that William Hallet etc. in a secret underhand way, had taken the children, two cows, all the household goods, and what else I know not, and by water were gone away ... when they had all the estate in their hands, the children went (if not naked) very unsatisfyingly apparelled.

John Winthrop Jr. interceded with Peter Stuyvesant in a letter in the beginning of 1648/9, asking him to manage what estate was left so that "Mrs. Feakes" and her children had a comfortable living. By the spring, Andrew Messenger was informing Winthrop that the estate at Greenwich was still unimproved. Winthrop wrote again in May to Stuyvesant, asking that he honor the agreement made between William Hallet with Mr. Feakes, Feakes having consented to it before going for England "knowing him [Hallet] to be industrious and careful" and also to allow Hallet back into Greenwich to improve the land there.
Evidently Stuyvesant came through, for Elizabeth (now Hallett) wrote last from Hellgate 10 January 1652/3 saying to her cousin John Winthrop Jr.:
"Our habitation is by the whirlpool which the Dutchmen call the Hellgate where we have purchased a very good farm through the governor's means ... we live very comfortably according to our rank. In the spring the Indian killed four Dutchmen near to our house which made us think to have removed ... yet now the Indian are quiet and we think not yet to remove."
The story of Elizabeth Fones (Winthrop) (Feake) Hallett was told in 1958 in an historical novel called The Winthrop Woman by Anya Seton