Friday, April 12, 2019

BARNUM, BRASS, AND BELLS: the “Other” Lydia Harris


SMITH-Dort/Winsor-Secord/HARRIS
Lydia Pitts Harris (1834-1917) 1st Cousin, 5x


Through the help of another descendant of my 5th great-grandparents, Asa Harris IV and Lydia Pitts, I discovered that their daughter Lydia (my 4GGM) had a niece who was also named Lydia: Lydia Pitts Harris. This “other” Lydia was a child of “our” Lydia’s brother, Lewis McCall Harris, who came to Michigan from New York, too. It was while examining his household listed in the 1860 U.S. Census that I discovered “The Peak Family Bell Ringers.”

In 1860, Lewis McCall, Sr., a brickmaker, and his wife Eliza were head of a large household in St. Joseph County that included their 24-year old daughter Lydia, her husband William H. Peak (Jr.) and their three-year old son, Frank. As occupation, all three Peaks were listed simply as “Peak Family Bell Ringers.” But, interestingly, so were the rest of Lydia’s siblings: Lewis M. Harris, Jr. (18), Henry D. (16), Eliza M. (14), Charles (12), and Asa P. (10). Not only were they all included as part of the troupe, but further down the list (along with other 5 other brickmakers listed in Lewis’ household), was even the person acting as agent for the Peak family performers.

By 1870, the Michigan town of Niles would not only be the home base of this Harris family, but also the Mid-West headquarters of The Peak Family Bell Ringers. So, who were they? To answer that question, we need to go back a generation, to William Peak’s father and a man called Phineas T. Barnum.
The Peak Family comes to town

While on a tour of England with the celebrated “General Tom Thumb,” Barnum attended a concert given by the Lancashire Bell Ringers and immediately signed them up to perform in America. The quintessential showman stipulated that they must grow Tyrolean-style mustaches and dress in colorful Swiss costumes so he could bill them as “Swiss Bell Ringers.” Although these English-born performers did tour in the States with Barnum, they soon returned to England, leaving their legendary bells behind. That’s where William H. Peak, Sr. entered the story.

Although accounts differ, it is thought that Barnum and the elder Peak became acquainted during a White House event where Barnum’s celebrated “Swiss” handbell-ringers performed along with other acts, including the talented vocalist, Peak. Following the disbanding of Barnum’s bell troupe in the late 1840’s, Peak supposedly purchased the set of bells from Barnum and soon incorporated them into his own company, naming it the “Peak Family Swiss Bell Ringers.”  In a newspaper article dated 1896, William H. Peak, Sr. reinforced Barnum’s mythical origins of the “Swiss” bells:
“It was in the early fifties, and all my children were able to perform well on the harp and other musical instruments, while my wife had gained fame everywhere with her soprano voice… Well, Barnum had just brought out some bell-ringers from Switzerland, and I saw and heard them at his American museum in New York. From that moment I was enthusiastic over Swiss bell-ringing, and importing my own bells from Switzerland, I organized the family troupe, which gained almost instantaneous popularity and distinction.”
Crawford Avalanche (Grayling, Michigan), March 12, 1896, p. 6

Under the direction of William Peak, Sr., this celebrated, musical touring company traveled to venues across the country from the early ‘40s until after the Civil War when it split into two regional troupes with son William stationed in the Mid-West. Just as he and his siblings brought their talents to his father’s original group, so William Jr. and wife Lydia (Harris) utilized family members to build their branch of “The Peak Family Bell Ringers.” The troupe, including Lydia’s brothers, was multi-talented, adding brass and stringed instruments to the increasingly popular bell-ringing performances.

By 1870, the dynamics of the group had changed, with Lydia and William, Jr. comfortably situated on a farm in Cass County and daughter Annie now married and keeping house. Of Lydia's brothers: Lewis had died of typhoid, and Asa would die two years later. Charles Harris and brother Henry were still active in the group, but even that wouldn’t last long. Lydia’s brother, Charles R. Harris had “other fish to fry”as we will see in the next blog post.

(l-r: Lewis M. Harris, Jr., Annie and Fannie Peak, Charles R. Harris) 


4 comments:

  1. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this article, however, in 1860, the family was located in White Pigeon Township, St. Joseph County, Michigan, as per the census.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Kelley! You are absolutely right and I have made the correction. I appreciate your input and interest.

      Delete
  2. Hi,
    Any idea how this story interacts with the Peake family, who sang in many Temperance meetings around the Boston area, 1846-8, and were from Medford, Massachusetts?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, the subject of this post, Lydia Pitts Harris, married William Henry Peak(e), Jr. of Medford. His father (originator of the bell-ringing family business) William, Sr., and mother, Mehitable, began as performing vocalists and raised a family of musicians, but unfortunately ended their days in a Cortland Co. NY 'poor house.'

      Delete